Evening Grosbeak or Yellow Grosbeak?

Here's how to tell the difference

Evening Grosbeak image 1
Evening Grosbeak image 2
Evening Grosbeak image 3
Evening Grosbeak image 4
Evening Grosbeak image 5
Evening Grosbeak image 6
Evening Grosbeak image 7
Evening Grosbeak image 8
Evening Grosbeak image 9
Evening Grosbeak image 10
Evening Grosbeak image 11

Evening Grosbeak

Tap To compare
Yellow Grosbeak image 1

Yellow Grosbeak

Evening Grosbeak

Hesperiphona vespertina

General appearance

The Evening Grosbeak is a stocky bird with a thick, stout bill. Its coloration is primarily that of yellow and black, with the body appearing mostly yellow and wings and tail being marked with black. The bill is a pale color, often appearing nearly white.

Male vs female

Males and females display significant sexual dimorphism. Males are more brightly colored, with a vibrant yellow body, a brownish-black head, and black wings featuring striking white patches. Females, on the other hand, are less vibrant with more of a grey-brown body and white markings on the wings. Both genders share the feature of a pale, stout bill.

Juvenile

Juvenile Evening Grosbeaks appear similar to adult females, with more subdued coloration than males. As they age, they gradually acquire their adult colors, males becoming vibrant yellow and females settling into their more muted brown and white tones.

Size

6.5 - 7.1 in/1.9 - 2.6 oz

There's more to learn about Evening Grosbeak

View full details

How to tell the Evening Grosbeak from the Yellow Grosbeak

Visual differences

The Evening Grosbeak is smaller, measuring 6.5-7 inches in length, while the Yellow Grosbeak is larger at 8.3-9.4 inches. The Evening Grosbeak has a vibrant yellow body with black wings and a pale bill, while the Yellow Grosbeak is bright yellow with black streaks and a blue-gray bill. The Evening Grosbeak's wings display prominent white patches, while the Yellow Grosbeak's wings are also black with white patches but have a tail stippled with white. Both species show sexual dimorphism, with females being duller than males.

Key differences and behavior

Evening and Yellow Grosbeaks exhibit distinct behavioral characteristics that aid in differentiation. Evening Grosbeaks, primarily found in cool, coniferous forests of North America, chiefly feed in groups, targeting seeds and insects, while Yellow Grosbeaks prefer subtropical/tropical dry forests in Central and South America, often foraging quietly alone or in pairs. Evening Grosbeaks display notable courtship through wing fluttering and vocalizations, whereas Yellow Grosbeaks sing complex songs and exhibit bright plumage. Nesting differs in choice of sites: the Evening in coniferous branches, and the Yellow in dense foliage or gardens. Both species, similar in size (about 2.1-2.6 oz, 6.5-9.5 in length), share seed and insect diets, but their habitat preferences and social behaviors in foraging and breeding set them apart.

Evening Grosbeak vs [Select a bird]

Yellow Grosbeak vs [Select a bird]

Select a bird icon

[Select a bird]

Pick a bird to compare