Screaming Cowbird or Brown-Headed Cowbird?
Here's how to tell the difference
Screaming Cowbird
Brown-Headed Cowbird
Screaming Cowbird
Molothrus rufoaxillaris
Screaming Cowbird Overview
The Screaming Cowbird, Molothrus rufoaxillaris, is a small bird species with fairly uniform plumage. Adult Screaming Cowbirds exhibit a striking black coloration that covers their entire body, including their head, back, and wings. The feathers often have a glossy sheen that reflects subtle hints of purple or blue in the right light. Their eyes are dark and beady, complementing their equally dark, stout bill which is perfectly adapted for their diverse diet.
Male vs Female Screaming Cowbird
There is little distinction between the male and female Screaming Cowbirds in terms of appearance. Both sexes share the same overall black plumage and size, making them challenging to differentiate. However, during the breeding season, males may be observed engaging in more vocal and conspicuous behaviors to attract mates, often perching in open areas and calling loudly.
Juvenile Screaming Cowbird
Juvenile Screaming Cowbirds differ notably from adults in terms of plumage coloration. These young birds usually present a more brownish hue, with patchy and less uniform feathering compared to the sleek black of adults. As they mature, their feathers gradually transition to the characteristic adult black. Juveniles are also readily identified by their relatively quieter demeanor, as they are less likely to engage in the distinctive loud calls until they approach adulthood.
Size
7.1 - 8.3 in/1.7 - 2.0 oz
There's more to learn about Screaming Cowbird
View full detailsBrown-Headed Cowbird
Molothrus ater
General appearance
The brown-headed cowbird is a medium-sized bird, approximately the size of a robin or sparrow, measuring between 6-8 inches or 15-20 cm. Its wing shape is broad and the tail is either rounded or square-tipped. The bird's coloration includes hues of black, brown, green, and tan.
Male vs female
In terms of gender differences, male brown-headed cowbirds are glossy black and sport a contrasting brown head. On the other hand, females have a different appearance, with a plain dusty brown color and a darker sparrowlike bill.
Juvenile
Juvenile brown-headed cowbirds have a unique appearance that changes as they mature. Initially, they are streaked and tend to resemble female adults but their coloration grows darker as they age. Further observation is needed to note if this pattern is consistent across all seasons.
Size
6.3 - 7.9 in/1.1 - 1.8 oz
There's more to learn about Brown-Headed Cowbird
View full detailsHow to tell the Screaming Cowbird from the Brown-Headed Cowbird
Visual differences
The Screaming Cowbird is slightly larger, weighing 1.7-2 oz and measuring 7-8 inches, compared to the Brown-Headed Cowbird's 1.1-1.8 oz and 6-8 inches. The Screaming Cowbird features more uniform dark plumage, while the male Brown-Headed Cowbird is glossy black with a contrasting brown head; females are plain, dusty brown. Juveniles of the Brown-Headed Cowbird start streaked and darken with age. Both species share a similar beak shape, but the Screaming Cowbird's overall darker appearance helps differentiate them from the Brown-Headed Cowbird.
Key differences and behavior
The Screaming Cowbird and Brown-Headed Cowbird both engage in brood parasitism, yet differ in preferred hosts; Screaming Cowbirds mainly target Bay-winged Cowbird nests, whereas Brown-Headed Cowbirds are less selective. Habitat-wise, Screaming Cowbirds inhabit southern South American grasslands, occasionally venturing into urban areas, while Brown-Headed Cowbirds frequent open U.S. countrysides. In feeding, both consume seeds and insects, but Screaming Cowbirds emphasize insects in warmer months and adapt to bird feeders, whereas Brown-Headed Cowbirds consume more seeds, especially in winter, following livestock for easy insect access. Despite similar courtship displays, Screaming Cowbirds vocalize loudly in small groups, while Brown-Headed Cowbirds engage in solo or group bowing displays.
Still not sure? Here are more lookalikes!
Brown-Headed Cowbird vs Red-Winged Blackbird
Brown-Headed Cowbird vs Brewer’s Blackbird
Brown-Headed Cowbird vs Common Grackle
Brown-Headed Cowbird vs Bronzed Cowbird
Brown-Headed Cowbird vs Shiny Cowbird
Screaming Cowbird vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare
Brown-Headed Cowbird vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare





