Red-Crested Cardinal or Red-Headed Cardinal?

Here's how to tell the difference

Red-Crested Cardinal image 1
Red-Crested Cardinal image 2
Red-Crested Cardinal image 3
Red-Crested Cardinal image 4
Red-Crested Cardinal image 5
Red-Crested Cardinal image 6
Red-Crested Cardinal image 7
Red-Crested Cardinal image 8
Red-Crested Cardinal image 9
Red-Crested Cardinal image 10
Red-Crested Cardinal image 11
Red-Crested Cardinal image 12
Red-Crested Cardinal image 13
Red-Crested Cardinal image 14
Red-Crested Cardinal image 15

Red-Crested Cardinal

Tap To compare
Red-Headed Cardinal image 1

Red-Headed Cardinal

Red-Crested Cardinal

Paroaria coronata

Also known as: Brazilian Cardinal

General appearance

The red-crested cardinal, also known as the Brazilian cardinal, is a bird species characterized by a vivid red head and crest contrasted with a grey body, black wings, and white underparts. Adults have a powerful, conical-shaped beak that is often gray-blue or dusky. They reach an average length between 17.5-20 cm. The species doesn't undergo any pronounced seasonal variations in appearance.

Male vs female

Both sexes display similar coloration; the males and females are almost identical in their plumage with no significant differences in size or color. This is a sexually monomorphic bird species, thus making it challenging to differentiate between males and females.

Juvenile

Juvenile red-crested cardinals differ from mature adults in their coloration. They have a dull overall color with lesser redness on the head, a sign of maturation. The young also have a less prominent crest and brownish hues in their plumage that gradually turn to the characteristic scarlet red as they mature.

Size

7.1 - 7.9 in/1.1 - 1.4 oz

There's more to learn about Red-Crested Cardinal

View full details

How to tell the Red-Crested Cardinal from the Red-Headed Cardinal

Visual differences

The Red-Crested Cardinal (7-8 inches) has a vivid red head and crest, gray body, black wings, and white underparts, with a powerful conical beak that's gray-blue or dusky. The Red-Headed Cardinal (6.5-7.5 inches) also displays a bright red head but includes a distinctive black mask; it has a conical sharp beak. Both sexes of each species appear similar. Juveniles of both species have duller coloring. The Red-Crested is marginally larger, while the Red-Headed sometimes shows slightly brighter males.

Key differences and behavior

The Red-Crested Cardinal and Red-Headed Cardinal exhibit distinct behaviors, aiding field identification. The Red-Crested Cardinal, found in South American shrublands and urban areas, builds nests in dense shrubs, with both parents sharing incubation and feeding duties for 2-3 young. They consume seeds, fruits, and insects and are frequent visitors to bird feeders. Conversely, the Red-Headed Cardinal resides in U.S. woodlands and migrates for winter, favoring suburban settings. During breeding, males perform elaborate courtship displays, and pairs build nests in low trees, feeding 2-4 chicks. Their diet similarly includes seeds, fruits, and insects, with frequent seed-based feeder visits. While both are monomorphic in appearance, the Red-Headed males sing more complex songs.

Still not sure? Here are more lookalikes!

Red-Crested Cardinal vs Red-Cowled Cardinal

Red-Headed Cardinal vs Red-Cowled Cardinal

Red-Crested Cardinal vs [Select a bird]

Select a bird icon

[Select a bird]

Pick a bird to compare

Red-Headed Cardinal vs [Select a bird]

Select a bird icon

[Select a bird]

Pick a bird to compare