Bulwer's Petrel or Barolo Shearwater?
Here's how to tell the difference
Bulwer's Petrel
Barolo Shearwater
Bulwer's Petrel
Bulweria bulwerii
General appearance
The Bulwer's Petrel is a medium-sized seabird characterized by its sleek, elongated body and narrow wings that enable graceful gliding over the water. Its plumage is primarily a dark chocolate brown, often appearing black in dim lighting. The head, back, and wings possess a slight sheen, adding to its striking appearance. The bird's bill is slender and black, complementing its streamlined body. Legs and feet are also dark, aiding in its inconspicuous presence at sea.
Male vs female
In Bulwer's Petrels, sexual dimorphism is minimal. Both males and females share similar size and coloration, making it difficult for observers to distinguish between the sexes. They are nearly identical in plumage and size, with no discernible differences in markings or color.
Juvenile
Juvenile Bulwer's Petrels closely resemble adults, sharing the same dark plumage. However, younger birds might display slightly more faded or dusky feathering compared to the polished look of mature adults. While the overall structure remains similar, juveniles might appear a bit scruffier as they transition into adults. Over time, their plumage gains the sheen characteristic of adult Bulwer's Petrels, completing their development.
Size
9.8 - 11.0 in/3.0 - 4.8 oz
There's more to learn about Bulwer's Petrel
View full detailsBarolo Shearwater
Puffinus baroli
General Appearance
The Barolo Shearwater is a small seabird, typically measuring about 27-30 cm in length with a wingspan ranging between 67-72 cm. Its plumage is predominantly black and white, with the upper parts including the back and wings being a rich black while the underparts, including the belly and underwings, are a bright white. A distinct and thin black band runs across the leading edges of the wings, visible in flight. Their beak is slender and dark gray, complementing their small rounded head. Legs and feet are also dark, often having a slightly bluish tint.
Male vs Female
The Barolo Shearwater shows no significant sexual dimorphism as both males and females have similar size and plumage. This similarity in appearance makes it challenging to distinguish their sexes visually in the wild. Observations during the breeding season might provide slight variations in behavior rather than physical characteristics. Hence, both sexes are equally involved in nesting duties, including incubation and feeding of the chicks.
Juvenile
Juvenile Barolo Shearwaters differ slightly from adults primarily in the sharpness and intensity of their plumage colors. Younger birds may appear duller with a less distinct contrast between the black and white areas. The feather edges in juveniles often have a slightly frayed look as they transition into adult plumage. As they mature, they quickly take on the brighter and more defined coloration seen in adults. However, there are no drastic changes in size or shape between juveniles and adults.
Size
11.0 - 13.0 in/6.0 oz
There's more to learn about Barolo Shearwater
View full detailsHow to tell the Bulwer's Petrel from the Barolo Shearwater
Visual differences
Bulwer's Petrel is smaller and lighter, weighing 3-4.8 ounces with a length of 9.8-11 inches, featuring uniform dark chocolate-brown plumage. In contrast, the Barolo Shearwater is heftier at 6 ounces with a length of 11-13 inches, and displays a striking black-and-white contrast, with a white underside and black upper parts. Bulwer's has a slender black bill, while Barolo's is more robust and dark. The distinct plumage styles and size differences are key visual identifiers between the two seabirds.
Key differences and behavior
Bulwer's Petrel and Barolo Shearwater, both nocturnal seabirds, exhibit distinct behavioral traits. Bulwer's Petrel, found in subtropical and tropical waters, prefers remote islands for nesting. Their breeding includes aerial acrobatics and calls, while they feed on small fish and squid at night, employing low-light vision. Barolo Shearwater inhabits temperate marine environments such as the Canary Islands, showcasing zigzag flight patterns and gentle cooing calls. They nest on cliffs, utilizing synchronized movements for courtship and rely on plunge-diving to catch fish. Both species form monogamous bonds, but Bulwer's Petrel exhibits a more humor-infused vocalization compared to the softer, melodic calls of Barolo Shearwater.
Still not sure? Here are more lookalikes!
Bulwer's Petrel vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare
Barolo Shearwater vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare