Bulwer's Petrel or Black Storm-Petrel?
Here's how to tell the difference
Bulwer's Petrel
Black Storm-Petrel
Bulwer's Petrel
Bulweria bulwerii
General appearance
The Bulwer's Petrel is a medium-sized seabird characterized by its sleek, elongated body and narrow wings that enable graceful gliding over the water. Its plumage is primarily a dark chocolate brown, often appearing black in dim lighting. The head, back, and wings possess a slight sheen, adding to its striking appearance. The bird's bill is slender and black, complementing its streamlined body. Legs and feet are also dark, aiding in its inconspicuous presence at sea.
Male vs female
In Bulwer's Petrels, sexual dimorphism is minimal. Both males and females share similar size and coloration, making it difficult for observers to distinguish between the sexes. They are nearly identical in plumage and size, with no discernible differences in markings or color.
Juvenile
Juvenile Bulwer's Petrels closely resemble adults, sharing the same dark plumage. However, younger birds might display slightly more faded or dusky feathering compared to the polished look of mature adults. While the overall structure remains similar, juveniles might appear a bit scruffier as they transition into adults. Over time, their plumage gains the sheen characteristic of adult Bulwer's Petrels, completing their development.
Size
9.8 - 11.0 in/3.0 - 4.8 oz
There's more to learn about Bulwer's Petrel
View full detailsBlack Storm-Petrel
Hydrobates melania
Characteristics of Black Storm-Petrel
General appearance: The Black Storm-Petrel is a small seabird that exhibits predominantly sooty black plumage. Its feathers have a slightly glossy appearance, particularly noticeable in good lighting. This bird features a distinctly long, forked tail and long, slender wings, which help it navigate agilely over the ocean surface. The feet are notably dark, contributing to its overall black appearance, with pale webbing sometimes visible in flight. Male vs female: There is minimal sexual dimorphism in Black Storm-Petrels, meaning males and females appear almost identical to the untrained observer. Both sexes share the same sooty black colorations, long wings, and tail structure. As such, visual identification based on sex is typically not possible. Juvenile: The juvenile Black Storm-Petrel closely resembles the adult in terms of plumage and physical structure. However, juveniles may have slightly duller feathers and a less glossy sheen compared to mature birds. Their rectrices may also be shorter and less sharply forked, which may aid in differentiation from adults upon close inspection. Over time, as these juveniles mature, they adopt the full characteristic features of their adult counterparts.
Size
8.7 - 9.8 in/1.2 - 2.1 oz
There's more to learn about Black Storm-Petrel
View full detailsHow to tell the Bulwer's Petrel from the Black Storm-Petrel
Visual differences
Bulwer's Petrel is larger, with a length of 9.8-11 inches and weight of 3-4.8 oz, compared to the Black Storm-Petrel, which measures 8.7-9.8 inches and weighs 1.2-2.1 oz. Bulwer's Petrel showcases a dark chocolate brown, slightly glossy plumage, while the Black Storm-Petrel is uniformly dark. Bulwer's has a slender, black bill and elongated wings, ideal for gliding, whereas the Black Storm-Petrel exhibits shorter wings and a more rapid, fluttery flight. Both species have minimal sexual dimorphism, complicating gender differentiation by appearance alone.
Key differences and behavior
Bulwer's Petrel and Black Storm-Petrel exhibit distinct behavioral differences. Bulwer's Petrel is nocturnally active, using darkness to hunt small fish and squid with its exceptional night vision, while Black Storm-Petrel primarily feeds during daylight, excelling at navigating weather changes. Both species nest on isolated islands, but Bulwer's Petrel favors burrow nests on cliffed islands globally, contrasted with Black Storm-Petrel's niche in rocky crevices along the eastern Pacific. Breeding is monogamous for both, marked by acrobatic displays; however, Black Storm-Petrels thrive in social colonies for predator detection. Bulwer's Petrel produces echoing calls compared to the quiet Black Storm-Petrel. These behavioral traits offer key field identification insights for seabird enthusiasts.
Still not sure? Here are more lookalikes!
Bulwer's Petrel vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare
Black Storm-Petrel vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare