Barolo Shearwater or Ashy Storm-Petrel?
Here's how to tell the difference
Barolo Shearwater
Ashy Storm-Petrel
Barolo Shearwater
Puffinus baroli
General Appearance
The Barolo Shearwater is a small seabird, typically measuring about 27-30 cm in length with a wingspan ranging between 67-72 cm. Its plumage is predominantly black and white, with the upper parts including the back and wings being a rich black while the underparts, including the belly and underwings, are a bright white. A distinct and thin black band runs across the leading edges of the wings, visible in flight. Their beak is slender and dark gray, complementing their small rounded head. Legs and feet are also dark, often having a slightly bluish tint.
Male vs Female
The Barolo Shearwater shows no significant sexual dimorphism as both males and females have similar size and plumage. This similarity in appearance makes it challenging to distinguish their sexes visually in the wild. Observations during the breeding season might provide slight variations in behavior rather than physical characteristics. Hence, both sexes are equally involved in nesting duties, including incubation and feeding of the chicks.
Juvenile
Juvenile Barolo Shearwaters differ slightly from adults primarily in the sharpness and intensity of their plumage colors. Younger birds may appear duller with a less distinct contrast between the black and white areas. The feather edges in juveniles often have a slightly frayed look as they transition into adult plumage. As they mature, they quickly take on the brighter and more defined coloration seen in adults. However, there are no drastic changes in size or shape between juveniles and adults.
Size
11.0 - 13.0 in/6.0 oz
There's more to learn about Barolo Shearwater
View full detailsAshy Storm-Petrel
Hydrobates homochroa
Ashy Storm-Petrel Recognition Guide
General appearance: The Ashy Storm-Petrel is a small, slate-gray seabird notable for its uniformly ashy coloration without any striking patterns or contrasts. This bird typically measures about 18 to 20 centimeters in length with long, slender wings spanning approximately 43 to 47 centimeters. Its plumage has a soft, sooty color throughout, mirrored by dark brownish hue in its long, slightly forked tail. The bird's head, back, wings, and upper parts are varying shades of ashy gray, lending it camouflage against the ocean's murky horizons. Male vs female: Both the male and female Ashy Storm-Petrels showcase similar morphologies and plumage characteristics. There are no conspicuous differences, and thus, distinguishing the sexes based on appearance alone can be challenging. Both sexes share identical coloration and size, making external identification in the field infeasible without behavioral context or genetic analysis. Juvenile: Juvenile Ashy Storm-Petrels bear a close resemblance to adult birds with only subtle differences in appearance. They generally display slightly paler or duller plumage and may lack the full depth of coloration seen in mature birds. As juveniles age, they gradually acquire the adult's consistent ashy gray tone, completing the transition in several months as they mature in the marine environment.
Size
7.1 - 8.3 in/1.2 - 1.9 oz
There's more to learn about Ashy Storm-Petrel
View full detailsHow to tell the Barolo Shearwater from the Ashy Storm-Petrel
Visual differences
Barolo Shearwater (length: 11-13 in, weight: 6 oz) is larger than the Ashy Storm-Petrel (length: 7-8 in, weight: 1.2-1.9 oz). The Shearwater sports a contrasting black and white plumage, whereas the Storm-Petrel features a uniform smoky gray coloring. Barolo Shearwater has a more substantial, robust body and a straighter beak adapted for fish catching; the Ashy Storm-Petrel is slender, with a built-for-skimming, shorter bill. These visual markers assist in distinguishing the larger, black-and-white Barolo Shearwater from the smaller, gray Ashy Storm-Petrel.
Key differences and behavior
The Barolo Shearwater (Puffinus baroli) and Ashy Storm-Petrel (Hydrobates homochroa) exhibit distinct behaviors to suit their environments. Barolo Shearwaters, weighing 6 ounces and spanning 11-13 inches, are agile nocturnal navigators, using stars and playful flight patterns as they traverse open oceans, primarily in the Atlantic. They breed in secluded cliffside burrows, sharing incubation duties equally between parents. Their diet consists of small fish and squid, foraging using plunge-diving techniques. Conversely, Ashy Storm-Petrels, lighter at 1.2-2 ounces and measuring 7-8 inches, thrive in the cooler coastal zones of the eastern North Pacific, engaging in nocturnal social displays. They nest on secluded islands, with the female primarily incubating eggs. They feed similarly to Barolo Shearwaters but may follow ships to feed on scraps. Both species avoid terrestrial bird feeders, relying solely on their oceanic environments.
Still not sure? Here are more lookalikes!
Ashy Storm-Petrel vs Wilson's Storm-Petrel
Ashy Storm-Petrel vs Fork-tailed Storm-Petrel
Ashy Storm-Petrel vs Townsend's Storm-Petrel
Barolo Shearwater vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare
Ashy Storm-Petrel vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare