Buller's Shearwater or Black-vented Shearwater?
Here's how to tell the difference
Buller's Shearwater
Black-vented Shearwater
Buller's Shearwater
Ardenna bulleri
Buller's Shearwater Identification Guide
The Buller's Shearwater is a striking medium-sized seabird identified by its sleek, aerodynamic body and graceful flight patterns. It possesses a striking appearance with dark gray upper parts contrasted by a pure white underbelly. The upper wings and back display a mix of gray and white patterns, which form a distinct 'M' shape when seen from above. The bird's tail is wedge-shaped, and its long, slender wings are adapted for gliding over the ocean. Males and females of the Buller's Shearwater are almost indistinguishable in appearance, exhibiting similar size and coloration. Both sexes share the same flattened bill and webbed feet, which are adaptations for their marine lifestyle. There is no significant sexual dimorphism, so distinguishing between them in the field can be challenging. Juvenile Buller's Shearwaters resemble adults but with subtle differences. Young birds often have slightly duller plumage and less distinct patterns on their upper parts. The 'M' pattern on the back may appear less prominent. Over time, as they mature and go through molt cycles, they attain the sharper contrast and clearer markings that characterize mature adults.
Size
18.1 in/15.0 - 17.5 oz
There's more to learn about Buller's Shearwater
View full detailsBlack-vented Shearwater
Puffinus opisthomelas
General Appearance
The Black-vented Shearwater is a medium-sized seabird featuring a streamlined body adapted for dynamic soaring. Its upperparts are primarily dark brown to charcoal, complemented by paler underparts, showcasing a striking contrast. Characteristically, it has a distinctive black ventral area which extends down to its undertail coverts. The bird's wings are long and tapered with pale grayish-white shading underneath, a key field mark during flight. Its bill is short, light gray with a hook at the tip, and the legs and feet are pink, providing subtle hints of color against its darker plumage.
Male vs Female
The Black-vented Shearwater exhibits minimal sexual dimorphism, making it challenging to distinguish between males and females through visual observation alone. Both sexes share the same plumage coloration, size, and shape, and typically weigh about the same, a common trait among many shearwater species. Behavioral observations during mating seasons might offer some differentiation, yet visually, they are largely indistinguishable.
Juvenile
Juvenile Black-vented Shearwaters closely resemble adults but can be identified by their slightly duller and softer plumage, which aids in camouflaging them from predators during their early life stages. They lack the more defined contrast seen in adults, appearing more uniformly gray. As juveniles grow and undergo their first molt, their plumage becomes more defined and similar to that of mature adults. Recognizing young birds in the field requires a keen eye for these subtle shifts in coloration and texture.
Size
11.8 - 16.9 in/8.9 - 13.4 oz
There's more to learn about Black-vented Shearwater
View full detailsHow to tell the Buller's Shearwater from the Black-vented Shearwater
Visual differences
Buller's Shearwater is larger, measuring about 18 inches in length, and weighs between 15-17.5 ounces, whereas the Black-vented Shearwater is smaller, 12-17 inches long, weighing 9-13.4 ounces. Buller's has a distinctive gray and white plumage with a bold "M" pattern on the back, contrasting with the Black-vented's more uniform dark brown and gray feathers. Buller's beak is longer and more slender, highlighting its streamlined appearance, while Black-vented has a shorter, more robust beak, complementing its compact form.
Key differences and behavior
Buller's Shearwater and Black-vented Shearwater differ notably in behavior and ecology. Buller's Shearwater is a long-distance migratory bird, traveling thousands of miles from New Zealand to the North Pacific's open waters, while Black-vented Shearwater is a coastal resident of the Baja California Peninsula, occasionally venturing to central California. Both birds engage in courtship behaviors, but Buller's Shearwater forms lasting pairs, usually nesting on isolated islands with burrowed tunnels, while Black-vented Shearwater favors sandy island soils for nesting. The diet for both includes fish and squid, but Buller's specializes in skimming for small fish and squid, whereas Black-vented is more opportunistic, often following fishing boats. Both species rely on marine ecosystems, with Black-vented being slightly more adaptable in diet.
Still not sure? Here are more lookalikes!
Black-vented Shearwater vs Barolo Shearwater
Black-vented Shearwater vs Black Storm-Petrel
Buller's Shearwater vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare
Black-vented Shearwater vs [Select a bird]
[Select a bird]
Pick a bird to compare